Eleventh Doctor “Scales” Waistcoat Analysis – Pockets

The 11th Doctor’s “scales” waistcoat (usually) had four welt pockets: an upper and lower pocket on each side.

Both sets of pockets slanted upward away from center.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS" (publicity photo)

Although pocket welts are sometimes cut on the crossgrain, the pocket welts on the “scales” waistcoat were cut on the straight grain (i.e. with the “scales” going in the same direction as the rest of the waistcoat front).

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x8 "The Rings of Akhaten" (publicity photo)
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x9 "Cold War" (publicity photo)

I found no visible evidence of any topstitching around the pocket welts, indicating that they were hand-sewn along the side edges.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS" (publicity photo)
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"

The precise positioning of the pocket welts may have slightly varied, but the lower centermost corners of the lower pocket welts were slightly higher than the second-lowest button.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS" (publicity photo)

In fact, using the “scales” as a guide, we can see that the pocket welt was positioned approximately ½” higher than the second-lowest button (measured from the buttonhole).

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
Doctor Who Experience (photo by Christopher Sos)

Although the lower front edge seems to have been cut on a slight curve and the pocket welts on straight lines, the lower pocket welts appear to have been angled approximately parallel to the lower front edges.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS”
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS”

The upper pocket welts appeared to be angled parallel to the lower pocket welts, although the upper welts were smaller than the lower ones.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS”
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS”

The precise positioning of the upper pocket welts may have varied slightly; at least, I had a difficult time ascertaining where, exactly, they were positioned.

Using the fabric “scales” for reference, the centermost upper corners of the upper pocket welts sometimes appeared to be level with the top buttonhole.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS”
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x9 "Cold War" (publicity photo)
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x10 "Hide"

More often, though, the centermost upper corners of the upper pocket welts seemed to be positioned below the top buttonhole … although again, the specific distance appeared to vary.

Sometimes it appeared to be a mere ¼” or so beneath the top button.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS" (publicity photo)
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x8 "The Rings of Akhaten"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"

Other times, though, that centermost upper corner of the upper pocket welt was noticeably lower than the top buttonhole.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"

In fact, it seems that sometimes the vertical placement of the upper pocket welts wasn’t even symmetrical!

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x10 "Hide"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS" (publicity photo)

An unfortunate (albeit somewhat amusing) continuity error with the “scales” waistcoat is that, for some reason, it didn’t always have all four pockets.

Specifically, the upper right pocket was sometimes missing.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x8 "The Rings of Akhaten" (publicity photo)
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x9 "Cold War" (publicity photo)

While it’s true that many waistcoats don’t have all four pockets, it’s also true that they don’t typically go appearing and disappearing again on the same waistcoat over the course of an hour or two!

At the beginning of the episode, “Journey to the Center of the TARDIS,” the Doctor’s waistcoat only had three pockets; there was no upper-right pocket.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
7x11 "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS"

However, after the TARDIS was “salvaged” and the Doctor was outside of the TARDIS, his waistcoat suddenly had four pockets!

His waistcoat continued to have all four pockets throughout the entire adventure inside the TARDIS.

But then, at the end of the episode, the upper right pocket magically disappeared again!

This is probably because the “normal” TARDIS scenes bookending the episode were filmed on the same day (or at least closely together), with the “meat” of the episode filmed at different points of the costumes’ production rotation.

Doctor Who has a built-in defense against continuity errors, though, especially during interior TARDIS scenes; during this episode in particular, there was all sorts of “timey wimey” stuff going on!

(And you might remember how the 10th Doctor’s suits would inexplicably switch versions during episodes, and even scenes.)

The “scales” waistcoat briefly seen near the beginning of “The Time of the Doctor” lacked the fourth, upper right pocket as well.

11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
8x02 "The Time of the Doctor"
11th Doctor "scales" waistcoat analysis
8x02 "The Time of the Doctor"
Share on facebook
Share on pinterest
Share on tumblr
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter